VicPD redacts own chief’s name while trying to obscure 2025 salaries

Over the past several years, VicPD has withheld more and more public information, attempting to hide things like how often they hit people with police cars, turn people over to the CBSA for deportation, or use force.

VicPD’s latest attempt at secrecy takes things a step further. In trying to obscure information about 2025 officer and staff salaries, VicPD withheld the name of its own police chief, arguing that releasing Chief Fiona Wilson’s name presented a security risk.

Secret police

VicPD doesn’t publicize what it pays individual employees except when forced to through freedom of information requests. Thanks to the work of the Vancouver Sun, in 2010, B.C.’s privacy commissioner ordered that as part of police salary disclosures under FOI, departments must release the names of officers who won’t be considered for undercover assignments due to their profile (chiefs, deputy chiefs, inspectors, media officers, and more), as well as all civilian staff.

For years, VicPD complied with this order. In 2024, for example, VicPD released names for 56 out of 284 positions (20%). Starting last year, however, VicPD stopped releasing any names. This year, they gave their reasons. They first cited the privacy commissioner’s ruling, which covers 80% of the names. They then said they were withholding “all names,” citing an obscure section of B.C.’s FOI legislation to argue that releasing them could “harm the security” of its property or systems.

Excerpt from VicPD’s cover letter explaining their redactions.

VicPD is misapplying a section of the law that’s meant to prevent the release of things like passwords and access codes, where their release presents a real and immediate security risk. That’s different from the names and salaries of public employees, which many public bodies are already legally required to make available.

VicPD’s misuse of FOI law, and their disregard for the privacy commissioner’s 2010 order, has created an absurd result where they’ve even withheld the names of Chief Wilson and outgoing Chief Manak, as well as officer and staff names that VicPD regularly publicizes as part of its own police board agendas.

2025 salary and expense information

VicPD did release salary information without names. Here’s what we now know about 2025 VicPD salaries, which is important context for when the next council starts wringing its hands about what programs and services to cut, all while shoveling money into this black hole. In 2025:

  • VicPD police officers made an average of $159,000

  • VicPD paid officers and staff $49.1 million, with $1.5 million in expenses

  • 184 VicPD constables made an average of $149,000

    • 7 constables made more than $200,000, topping out at $240,000

    • For context, see this past FOI on VicPD overtime

  • 42 VicPD sergeants made an average of $180,000

  • 10 VicPD staff sergeants made an average of $203,000

  • VicPD’s director of information risk management, responsible for VicPD’s “internal AI tool,” was the top-earning civilian staff member, at $209,000

  • 6 VicPD inspectors made an average of $213,000

  • The top-earning deputy chief made $267,000

  • 67 officers and staff had over $5,000 in expenses, with 20 of those people having expenses over $10,000

  • VicPD hired Chief Wilson partway through 2025, but per a CTV FOI, we know she started at an annual salary of $350,000

Additional compensation for Wilson, according to CTV, included a vehicle and $20,000 in moving expenses. This latest FOI suggests Wilson’s total expenses for 2025 were $43,000, while the outgoing Chief Manak had $23,000 in expenses. But it could always be the reverse – VicPD withheld both their names.

VicPD attempts to limit access to public information

Here’s an example of VicPD’s excessive redaction, where they withheld the names of a public-facing communications staff member, an inspector (one rank below deputy chief), and the police chief.

Screenshot from VicPD’s FOI response.

Using the advanced tools of 1) Alphabetical order, and 2) Things VicPD publishes themselves, in this example we can reasonably conclude that VicPD has redacted the names of: Cheryl Major, Director, Community Engagement; Inspector Jan Malinosky; and outgoing Chief Del Manak.

Compare VicPD’s redactions above to recent police board minutes that name VicPD’s then-chief, deputy chiefs, three inspectors, four staff sergeants, and multiple staff. Major, Malinosky, and Manak are all named, and their full names can be found in the same agenda. All somehow without creating a risk to VicPD’s systems.

Excerpt of VicPD police board minutes from a February 2025 public agenda.

Unless VicPD officers are using their salaries as their passwords, releasing staff and public-facing officers’ names alongside their salaries poses no risk to VicPD’s systems greater than information VicPD already willingly discloses. Per past OIPC orders, “merely possible or speculative” risks aren’t enough to withhold information the way VicPD has done here.

VicPD is a public body, but they increasingly appear to be upset that access to information laws exist at all, as they regularly obstruct information requests in an effort to reduce unwanted transparency and exhaust applicants. It’s worth noting that VicPD released these excessively redacted records after the legal deadline, and only after an appeal to the privacy commissioner.

While VicPD will likely be forced to disclose the names they withheld after a second appeal, it may take months or longer to get VicPD to obey the law.

Name tag graphic modified from FreeSVG.org

author